On a $40 item with $6 shipping, Etsy keeps about $4.82, or 10.5% of the order, and $10.34 to $11.72 when the sale came through an Offsite Ad. Shopify Basic keeps $1.63 in card fees plus a $29 to $39 monthly plan, but sends you no buyers, so the real question is whether you can find customers for less than that difference. At a typical 1.4% conversion rate the difference pays for only about 3 to 11 cents per visitor, which is why most sellers who move do best when they already have repeat buyers, a following or wholesale accounts. Etsy also keeps the customer: its rules bar marketing to Etsy buyers without their consent and steering them to buy elsewhere.
Most Etsy vs Shopify comparisons line up the fees and declare a winner. That misses how the decision actually feels when it is your shop. Etsy is a busy market where you rent a stall, and the rent goes up as you sell more. Shopify is an empty shop on a street nobody has heard of yet. The rent is low, and the customers are your problem.
This guide works through both from the seller's side, using Etsy's published US fees, Shopify's US pricing as of November 2026 and Etsy's own quarterly results. Sales tax is left out of the examples to keep the arithmetic readable.
Etsy vs Shopify at a glance
| Etsy | Shopify | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly cost | None required. Etsy Plus is optional at $10 a month | Basic $39 a month, or $29 billed yearly |
| Fees on each sale | 6.5% transaction fee plus 3% and $0.25 processing, plus $0.20 a listing | 2.9% and $0.30 with Shopify Payments on Basic |
| Advertising fee | 12% or 15% on sales from Offsite Ads, mandatory once you pass $10,000 a year | None. You choose and pay for your own ads |
| Who brings the buyers | Etsy, about 88 million active buyers | You |
| What you can sell | Items you make, design, handpick or source under Etsy's Creativity Standards | Anything legal that Shopify's terms allow |
| Customer emails | For the order only. No marketing without the buyer's consent | Yours, for customers who opt in |
| Look and brand | Etsy's page layout, competitors shown beside you | Your own design and domain |
| Payouts | Etsy can hold part of your sales in a reserve | Paid out on Shopify's normal schedule |
What Etsy takes from one order
Take a $40 item with $6 shipping, so the buyer pays $46. These are Etsy's US fees from its fee schedule, with Shopify Basic beside them.
| On a $46 order | Etsy, normal sale | Etsy, Offsite Ads sale (12%) | Etsy, Offsite Ads sale (15%) | Shopify Basic |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Listing fee | $0.20 | $0.20 | $0.20 | None |
| Transaction fee, 6.5% including shipping | $2.99 | $2.99 | $2.99 | None |
| Payment processing | $1.63 | $1.63 | $1.63 | $1.63 |
| Offsite Ads fee | None | $5.52 | $6.90 | None |
| Total fees | $4.82 (10.5%) | $10.34 (22.5%) | $11.72 (25.5%) | $1.63 (3.5%) plus the plan |
Three details change the picture.
- Etsy charges on shipping too. The 6.5% transaction fee and the processing fee both apply to what the buyer pays for shipping, so raising your shipping price to cover costs also raises your fees.
- The listing fee repeats. Each listing costs $0.20 for four months and renews automatically, and every extra unit sold in a multi-quantity order costs another $0.20. With hundreds of listings this becomes a steady monthly bill of its own.
- Shopify's plan is fixed. At 20 orders a month, a $39 plan adds about $1.95 to every order. At 200 orders it adds about 20 cents. Shopify gets cheaper per order as you grow. Etsy does not.
The fee most Etsy sellers find out about late: Offsite Ads
Etsy advertises listings on Google, social media and other sites, and when a shopper clicks one of those ads and buys from you within 30 days, Etsy charges an advertising fee on that order. According to Etsy's help pages, the fee is 15% of the order for shops that have never made $10,000 in a 365-day period, and 12% for shops that have, capped at $100 per order.
The part that matters for planning is the switch. Below $10,000 a year you can opt out. Once your shop crosses $10,000, Offsite Ads become mandatory for the life of the shop. A seller who is growing on Etsy is therefore also growing the share of sales that carries a 12% fee, without choosing to and without seeing the ad.
This is why Etsy's own figures look the way they do. In its third-quarter 2026 shareholder letter, Etsy's revenue came to 26.2% of everything buyers spent on the marketplace, up half a point on a year earlier, driven mostly by advertising. That figure includes things sellers choose to buy, such as Etsy Ads and shipping labels, so it is not what every seller pays. It does show where the platform's growth is coming from.
What Shopify costs that the price page leaves out
Shopify's pricing page is honest about what it charges. What it cannot show is the cost of getting someone to your store, because on Shopify that is entirely yours.
Here is a simple way to see it. Using the $46 order and a Shopify Basic store doing 50 orders a month, Shopify's fees come to about $2.41 per order including the plan. Etsy's normal fees are $4.82, so the Shopify store keeps $2.41 more per sale. If the Etsy sale had come through an Offsite Ad at 12%, the Shopify store keeps $7.93 more.
That difference is your budget for finding the buyer yourself. Littledata, an analytics company that measures Shopify stores, puts the median store's conversion rate at 1.4% over the three months to mid-November 2026. At 1.4%, about 71 visitors make one sale. So the extra margin pays for about 3 cents per visitor against a normal Etsy sale, and about 11 cents against an Offsite Ads sale.
Paid ads rarely bring a visitor that cheaply. That leads to the most useful sentence in this guide: your own store pays when most of its visitors arrive for free. Repeat customers, people who follow you on social media, people who search for your brand by name, wholesale buyers and word of mouth all cost little or nothing per visit. A store that depends on paid ads for every visitor usually does worse than Etsy until its repeat business builds up.
Who owns the customer
Fees are the visible cost. Control is the one sellers mention when they explain why they left.
- You cannot market to Etsy buyers without their consent. Etsy told sellers in January 2024 that they should never copy email addresses from Etsy orders into a mailing list, and since February 2024 third-party apps receive buyer emails only when they need them to fulfil an order.
- You cannot steer Etsy buyers to buy elsewhere. Etsy's off-platform transactions policy bars taking a sale or the conversation about it off Etsy, and reporting on its seller policy update of July 2026 says it now names discounts for buying through another website as an example. Read Etsy's current seller policy before you put anything about your own website in an Etsy listing, message or package.
- Etsy can hold your money. Payment reserves can apply to a new shop's first sales, a sudden rise in orders or refunds, late shipping or intellectual property reports, and support staff cannot remove them. Etsy says most are lifted within 90 days.
- What you sell is Etsy's decision. Since July 2024 every item must fit Etsy's Creativity Standards: made by you, designed by you, handpicked by you (such as vintage at least 20 years old) or sourced by you (such as craft supplies). Reselling mass-produced goods is not allowed, and production partners must be disclosed.
- Your ranking is Etsy's decision too. Etsy search weighs relevance, clicks and sales, listing quality, reviews, message response times and shipping price. A change to that system can move your sales overnight, and there is no one to call.
None of this makes Etsy a bad deal. It means an Etsy shop is a sales channel, not an asset. On Shopify the customer list, the design, the address and the search rankings belong to you, and they keep their value if you ever sell the business.
How crowded is Etsy now?
Etsy's marketplace had about 88 million active buyers over the twelve months to September 2026, its first year-on-year rise in two years, and sales on the marketplace grew 8.8% in the quarter. Active sellers reached about 5.8 million, the fastest growth in two years, as Value Added Resource reported from the results.
That works out to roughly 15 active buyers for every active seller. Etsy still brings real demand, and it is growing again after a weak 2024 and 2025. But more sellers are competing for each shopper, which is where paid Etsy Ads and the Offsite Ads fee earn their place in Etsy's revenue.
Which one is right for your business?
Stay on Etsy when
- Most of your sales come from shoppers finding you in Etsy search, not from people who already know you.
- You sell one-off, personalised or handmade pieces that Etsy shoppers are looking for.
- You are under about $10,000 a year and can keep Offsite Ads switched off.
- You do not have time to run your own marketing every week.
Move your main business to Shopify when
- A real share of buyers come back, or find you through social media, events or word of mouth.
- Offsite Ads are taking 12% of a meaningful share of your orders.
- You want an email list, your own design, bundles, subscriptions or wholesale pricing.
- You are building a brand you might one day sell, and you want the customer relationships to come with it.
Run both when
- Etsy still finds you new customers, and your own store serves the people who come looking for you.
- You can keep stock in step across both. Shopify's Marketplace Connect app currently does not accept new Etsy connections, so this needs a separate integration app or careful manual work. Overselling the last unit on two channels is the most common problem.
If you also sell on Amazon, our Shopify vs Amazon comparison covers the same question for a marketplace that works very differently from Etsy.
Moving from Etsy to Shopify: what comes with you
- Listings. Etsy's Download Data page exports active listings as a CSV with titles, descriptions, prices, quantities, tags and image links, which can be reshaped into Shopify's product import format.
- Orders and reviews. Orders export as CSV and reviews as a data file. Review apps for Shopify can import reviews, but check Etsy's current terms before you display them on your own site.
- Customers. Not as a marketing list. Your Shopify list starts with people who opt in on your store.
- Search rankings. They stay with Etsy. Your Etsy listing pages cannot be redirected to your new store, so your own site starts its search history from zero. Plan on months, not weeks, before it brings meaningful traffic. Our guide to keeping rankings through a migration covers the parts you do control.
Most sellers we would advise keep the Etsy shop open during the move and let the numbers decide when it has stopped earning its fees. If you are new to the platform, how Shopify works walks through the setup from the start.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Etsy or Shopify cheaper?
Per sale, Shopify is cheaper. On a $46 order Etsy's standard fees come to about $4.82 and Shopify Basic's card fee to $1.63. But Shopify charges a monthly plan, from $29 a month billed yearly, and brings you no shoppers, so once you count what it costs to find a buyer, Etsy is often cheaper for a small shop.
How much does Etsy take from a sale?
In the US, a $0.20 listing fee, a 6.5% transaction fee on the order total including shipping, and 3% plus $0.25 for payment processing. On a $40 item with $6 shipping that is about $4.82, or 10.5%. If the sale came from an Offsite Ad, add 12% or 15% of the order, capped at $100.
Can I turn off Etsy Offsite Ads?
Only until your shop has made $10,000 in any 365-day period. After that, Offsite Ads are mandatory for the life of the shop, at 12% of each order that came from an ad, capped at $100 per order.
Can I sell on Etsy and Shopify at the same time?
Yes, and many sellers do. Shopify's own Marketplace Connect app no longer accepts new Etsy connections, so you need a separate integration app to keep stock and orders in step, or you manage the two by hand. Keep the product details consistent and watch stock closely, because two channels selling the same item is where overselling starts.
Can I take my Etsy customers with me to Shopify?
Not directly. You can export your listings, orders and reviews from Etsy, but Etsy's rules say you must not copy buyers' email addresses from orders into a mailing list without their consent, and you must not steer Etsy buyers to buy elsewhere. Your Shopify customer list has to be built from people who opt in through your own store.
When should I move from Etsy to Shopify?
When you have a reason for buyers to come to you directly: repeat customers, a social following, wholesale accounts or a product people search for by your brand name. If nearly all your sales still come from Etsy search, add a Shopify store alongside Etsy rather than leaving it.